JIANG Zhi-Bing, ZENG Jiang-Ning, CHEN Quan-Zhen, LIAO Yi-Bo, XU Xiao-Qun, SHOU Lu, LIU Jing-Jing, GAO Ai-Gen, ZHAO Yong-Qiang, HUANG Yi-Jun. TOXIC ITY OF RES IDUAL CHLORINE ON COPEPODS UNDER TEMPERATURE INCREASE IN D IFFERENT SEASONS[J]. ACTA HYDROBIOLOGICA SINICA, 2009, 33(5): 896-904.
Citation: JIANG Zhi-Bing, ZENG Jiang-Ning, CHEN Quan-Zhen, LIAO Yi-Bo, XU Xiao-Qun, SHOU Lu, LIU Jing-Jing, GAO Ai-Gen, ZHAO Yong-Qiang, HUANG Yi-Jun. TOXIC ITY OF RES IDUAL CHLORINE ON COPEPODS UNDER TEMPERATURE INCREASE IN D IFFERENT SEASONS[J]. ACTA HYDROBIOLOGICA SINICA, 2009, 33(5): 896-904.

TOXIC ITY OF RES IDUAL CHLORINE ON COPEPODS UNDER TEMPERATURE INCREASE IN D IFFERENT SEASONS

  • Received Date: January 31, 2008
  • Rev Recd Date: December 28, 2008
  • Published Date: September 24, 2009
  • With the drastic increase number of large-sized thermal (nuclear) power plants along the coastal areas,theamage of zoop lankton caused by chlorination in cooling water has become a serious marine ecological safety problem inhina1 Unfortunately,very little work has been carried out on the tolerance of copepods to the chlorination1 Moreover,here is no discharge criterion of the residual chlorine level in coastal power plants cooling systems in country1 The majorbjectives of this study are to 1) study the tolerances ofmarine copepods to residual chlorine under different thermal shockemperature,-) supp ly scientific basis for chlorination and residual chlorine risk assessment during environmental evalua-ion,and 3) provide suggestions for regulation about the drainage standard of residual chlorine concentration in coolingater1he experimental following twelve copepod species were collected from the Yueqing Bay in all the seasons: Calanusinicus,Labidocera euchaeta,Eucalanus subcrassus,Paracalanus aculeatus,Paracalanus crassirostris,Centropagesorsispinatus,Euchaeta concinna,S inocalanus tenellus,Calanopia thompsoni,Acartia pacifica,Acartia spinicauda andarpacticus unirem is. At each samp ling time (08/-006,11/-006,01/-007 and 05/-007),the natural water tempera-ures were -810,-110,1010 and 1610℃,respectively1 After two days’laboratory maintenance,healthy adult animalsere chlorine dosed for 30 min under different temperature increases (ΔT) (0,410,810 and 1-10℃) 1 The median le-hal concentration (LC50 ) of experimental species to residual chlorine was determined by theirmortalities after -4h accord-ng to the probit analysis1he results showed that the LC50 of experimental copepod species to residual chlorine decreased conspicuously withhe rising ofΔT (P e.g. P. aculeatus,P. crassirostris,A. pacifica and A. spinicauda) were more sensitive to theesidual chlorine than the larger ones (C. sinicus,L. euchaeta,E. subcrassus and E. concinna) 1 Thus,the copepod spe-ies diversity might reduce and the composition of copepod communities might simp lify due to the chlorination in coolingaters1f the safe concentration of residual chlorine on copepodswas determined by the formulation of LC50 ×015,the safeoncentration of various copepod species in spring,autumn and winter were 01-1-0186 mg/L,01-6-0186 mg/L and131-4155 mg/L,respectively,as the exposure duration ≤ 30 min andΔT ≤ 1-10℃,while the safe concentration ofarious copepod species were 0115-0137 mg/L as the exposure duration ≤ 30min andΔT ≤ 810℃ in summer1 Basedn these data,the current typical chlorination with high dosage (about - mg/L) affected the copepods in the coastal power lants cooling systems,but the common discharging residual chlorine (about 0115-01-5 mg/L) did not influence them1s far as the marine ecological protection was concerned,in subtropical area,the discharging residual chlorine levelhould not exceed 0115 mg/L in summer and 01-0 mg/L in the rest of seasons based on the safe concentration of small-sized copepod specieswhich were sensitive to the chlorination in different seasons1 However,during the criteria regulationbout the discharging level of residual chlorine,whether this residual chlorine at certain chlorine dosage could effectively revent the cooling systems from biofouling should be considered,achieving the op timal distribution of environmental risknd economic benefit1ore researches should be conducted to examine the LC50 of dominant copepods and other hydrobios (e.g. zoop lank-on,fish and shellfish) to residual chlorine in different regions,and it is also necessary to study the toxicity of residualhlorine on the marine organisms under different conditions,such as temperature,salinity,water pressure,pH and expo-ure duration1 Besides,further work should be required to assess the long-term response of the copepod community underhe chlorination stress of coastal power plants
  • [1]
    Jenner H A, Taylor C J L, Donk V, et al. Chlorination by2p rod2cts in chlorinated cooling water of some European coastal powertations [J]. M ar. Environ. Res., 1997, 43 (4) : 279-293
    [2]
    AllonierA S, KhalanskiM, Camel V, et al. Characterization ofhlorination by2p roducts in cooling effluents of coastal nuclearower Stations [J]. M ar. Pollut. B ull., 1999, 38 ( 12 ) :232-1241
    [3]
    Liu L F, Hao H, Lu G S. Experiment study on attenuation law ofesidual chlorine in cooling water discharged from thermal power lants [J]. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 2004, (5) : 94-8 [刘兰芬, 郝红, 鲁光四. 电厂温排水中余氯衰减规律及影响因素的实验研究. 水利学报, 2004, (5) : 94-98]

    Liu L F, Hao H, Lu G S. Experiment study on attenuation law ofesidual chlorine in cooling water discharged from thermal power lants [J]. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 2004, (5) : 94-8 [刘兰芬, 郝红, 鲁光四. 电厂温排水中余氯衰减规律及影响因素的实验研究. 水利学报, 2004, (5) : 94-98]
    [4]
    Bamber R N, Seaby RM H. The effects of power station entrain2ent passage on three species of marine p lanktonic crustacean,cartia tonsa (Copepoda), Crangon crangon (Decapoda) andom arus gamm arus (Decapoda ) [J]. M ar. Environ. Res.,004, 57 (4) : 281-294
    [5]
    J iang Z B, Zeng J N, Chen Q Z, et al. Effect of residual heatnd chlorine in coolingwater from coastal power p lant on Calanusinicus [J]. Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology, 2008, 19 (6) :401-1406 [江志兵, 曾江宁, 陈全震, 等. 滨海电厂冷却余热和余氯对中华哲水蚤的影响. 应用生态学报, 2008,9 (6) : 1401-1406

    J iang Z B, Zeng J N, Chen Q Z, et al. Effect of residual heatnd chlorine in coolingwater from coastal power p lant on Calanusinicus [J]. Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology, 2008, 19 (6) :401-1406 [江志兵, 曾江宁, 陈全震, 等. 滨海电厂冷却余热和余氯对中华哲水蚤的影响. 应用生态学报, 2008,9 (6) : 1401-1406
    [6]
    Zeng J N, Chen Q Z, Zheng P, et al. Advance in effect of resid2al chlorine on hydrobios [J]. Acta Ecological S inica, 2005, 2510) : 2717-2724 [曾江宁, 陈全震, 郑平, 等. 余氯对于生生物的影响. 生态学报, 2005, 25 (10) : 2717-2724]

    Zeng J N, Chen Q Z, Zheng P, et al. Advance in effect of resid2al chlorine on hydrobios [J]. Acta Ecological S inica, 2005, 2510) : 2717-2724 [曾江宁, 陈全震, 郑平, 等. 余氯对于生生物的影响. 生态学报, 2005, 25 (10) : 2717-2724]
    [7]
    Meng Z Q. Princip les and Methods of Ecotoxicology [M]. Bei2ing: Science Press. 2006, 519 [孟紫强. 生态毒理学原理与法. 北京: 科学出版社, 2006, 519]

    Meng Z Q. Princip les and Methods of Ecotoxicology [M]. Bei2ing: Science Press. 2006, 519 [孟紫强. 生态毒理学原理与法. 北京: 科学出版社, 2006, 519]
    [8]
    Marumo K, Sato F, Ishikawa Y. Experimental study on acuteffects of the combined exposure to temperature increase andhlorination upon the marine copepod Acartia om orii [J]. M ar. iol., 1992, 114 (2) : 235-240
    [9]
    Liu Z S, Wang C S, Zhang Z N, et al. Seasonal dynamics andrazing rate of zoop lankton in Yueqing Bay [J]. Acta Ecological inica, 2005, 25 (8 ) : 1853-1862 [刘镇盛, 王春生, 张志, 等. 乐清湾浮游动物的季节变动及摄食率. 生态学报,005, 25 (8) : 1853-1862]

    Liu Z S, Wang C S, Zhang Z N, et al. Seasonal dynamics andrazing rate of zoop lankton in Yueqing Bay [J]. Acta Ecological inica, 2005, 25 (8 ) : 1853-1862 [刘镇盛, 王春生, 张志, 等. 乐清湾浮游动物的季节变动及摄食率. 生态学报,005, 25 (8) : 1853-1862]
    [10]
    Huang H H, Zhang S, Chen H R, et al. Studies on toxicity ofesidual chlorine to larvae of Rhabdosargus sarba and Spaus m ac2ocephalus in Daya Bay [J]. Tropic Oceanology, 1999, 18 (3) :8-44 [黄洪辉, 张穗, 陈浩如, 等. 余氯对大亚湾海区平和黑鲷幼鱼的毒性研究. 热带海洋, 1999, 18 ( 3) : 38-4]

    Huang H H, Zhang S, Chen H R, et al. Studies on toxicity ofesidual chlorine to larvae of Rhabdosargus sarba and Spaus m ac2ocephalus in Daya Bay [J]. Tropic Oceanology, 1999, 18 (3) :8-44 [黄洪辉, 张穗, 陈浩如, 等. 余氯对大亚湾海区平和黑鲷幼鱼的毒性研究. 热带海洋, 1999, 18 ( 3) : 38-4]
    [11]
    Zhou Y X, Zhang Z S. Methods of Toxicity Tests on Hydrobio[M]. Beijing: Agriculture Press. 1989, 266 [周永欣, 章宗. 水生生物毒性试验方法. 北京: 农业出版社. 1989,66]

    Zhou Y X, Zhang Z S. Methods of Toxicity Tests on Hydrobio[M]. Beijing: Agriculture Press. 1989, 266 [周永欣, 章宗. 水生生物毒性试验方法. 北京: 农业出版社. 1989,66]
    [12]
    Rajagopal S, SasikumarN, Azariah J, et al. How effective is in2ermittent chlorination to control adult mussel fouling in coolingater systems [J] ? W ater Res., 2003, 37 (2) : 329-338
    [13]
    Margrey S L, Burton D T, J r Hall L W. Seasonal temperaturend power p lant chlorination effects on estuarine invertebrates[J]. A rch. Environ. Conram. Toxicol., 1981, 10 ( 6 ) :91-703
    [14]
    J iang Z B, Zeng J N, Chen Q Z, et al. Potential impact of risingeawater temperature on copepods due to coastal power p lants inubtrop ical areas [J]. J. Exp. Mar. B iol. Ecol., 2009, 3682) : 196-201
    [15]
    Zeng J N, J iang Z B, Chen Q Z, et al. Upper incip ient lethalemperature of short term thermal shock of two species of cope2ods [J]. Acta Ecological S inica, 2009, 29 ( 1 ) : 532-537[曾江宁, 江志兵, 陈全震, 等. 两种桡足类短期热冲击的高始致死温度. 生态学报, 2009, 29 (1) : 532-537]

    Zeng J N, J iang Z B, Chen Q Z, et al. Upper incip ient lethalemperature of short term thermal shock of two species of cope2ods [J]. Acta Ecological S inica, 2009, 29 ( 1 ) : 532-537[曾江宁, 江志兵, 陈全震, 等. 两种桡足类短期热冲击的高始致死温度. 生态学报, 2009, 29 (1) : 532-537]
    [16]
    Capuzzo J M, Lawrence S A, Davidson J. Combined toxicity ofree chlorine, chloramine and temperature to stage 1 larvae of themerican lobster Hom arus am ericanus [J]. W ater Res., 1976,0 (12) : 1093-1099
    [17]
    Clarke A, Fraser K P P. Why does metabolism scale with tem2erature [J] ? Funct. Ecol., 2004, 18 (2) : 243-251]
    [18]
    Kong X H, Wang G Z, Li S J. Changes of antioxidant defense,TPase activity and cellmembrane fatty acid composition in Gillf Scylla serrata under low temperature acclimation [J]. Actaydrobiological S inica, 2007, 31 (1) : 59-66 [孔祥会, 王桂, 李少菁. 低温驯化锯缘青蟹鳃抗氧化防护、ATPase及膜肪酸组成变化. 水生生物学报, 2007, 31 (1) : 59-66]

    Kong X H, Wang G Z, Li S J. Changes of antioxidant defense,TPase activity and cellmembrane fatty acid composition in Gillf Scylla serrata under low temperature acclimation [J]. Actaydrobiological S inica, 2007, 31 (1) : 59-66 [孔祥会, 王桂, 李少菁. 低温驯化锯缘青蟹鳃抗氧化防护、ATPase及膜肪酸组成变化. 水生生物学报, 2007, 31 (1) : 59-66]
    [19]
    Li C, Sun S, Wang R, et al. Feeding and resp iration rates of a lanktonic copepod (Calanus sinicus) oversummering in Yellowea Cold Bottom Waters [J]. M ar. B iol., 2004, 145 ( 1 ) :49-457
    [20]
    Capuzzo J M. The effect of temperature on the toxicity of chloriated cooling waters to marine animals: A p reliminary review[J]. M ar. Pollut. B ull., 1979, 10 (2) : 45-47
    [21]
    RobertsM H J r, Diaz R J, BenderM E, et al. Acute toxicity ofhlorine to selected estuarine species [J]. J. Fish Res. B oardan., 1975, 32 (12) : 2525-2528
    [22]
    Heinle D R. Effects of passage through power p lant cooling sys2ems on estuarine copepods [J]. Environ. Pollut., 1976, 111) : 39-58
    [23]
    Shu Y F, Han M S. Marine Plankton of China Illustrate [M].eijing: Ocean Press. 1992, 224 [束蕴芳, 韩茂森. 中国海洋游生物图谱. 北京: 海洋出版社. 1992, 224]

    Shu Y F, Han M S. Marine Plankton of China Illustrate [M].eijing: Ocean Press. 1992, 224 [束蕴芳, 韩茂森. 中国海洋游生物图谱. 北京: 海洋出版社. 1992, 224]
    [24]
    Duffy J E, Stachowicz J J. Why biodiversity is important to ocea2ography: potential roles of genetic, species, and trophic diversi2y in pelagic ecosystem p rocesses [J]. M ar. Ecol. Prog. Ser.,006, 311: 179-189
    [25]
    Gei J W, Cai Q H, Liu J K. A new method for economic valuevaluation of aquatic biodiversity: wildlife judicial p rice method[J]. Acta Hydrobiologica S inica, 2006, 30 (1) : 126-128 [葛继, 蔡庆华, 刘健康. 水域生态系统中生物多样性经济价值评的一个新方法. 水生生物学报, 2006, 30 (1) : 126-128]

    Gei J W, Cai Q H, Liu J K. A new method for economic valuevaluation of aquatic biodiversity: wildlife judicial p rice method[J]. Acta Hydrobiologica S inica, 2006, 30 (1) : 126-128 [葛继, 蔡庆华, 刘健康. 水域生态系统中生物多样性经济价值评的一个新方法. 水生生物学报, 2006, 30 (1) : 126-128]
    [26]
    Walker B H. Biology diversity and ecological redundancy [J].onser. B iol., 1992, 6 (1) : 18-23
    [27]
    Latimer D L, Brooks A S, Beeton A M. Toxicity of 302minutexposures of residual chlorine to the copepodsL im nocalanusm ac2urus and Cyclop s bicuspidatus thom asi [J]. J. Fish Res. B oardan., 1975, 32 (12) : 2495-2510
    [28]
    Mattice J S, Zittel H E. Site2specific evaluation of power p lanthlorination [J]. J. W ater Pollut. Control Fed., 1976, 4810) : 2284-2302
    [29]
    BrooksA S, Seegert G L. The effects of intermittent chlorinationn rainbow trout and yellow perch [J]. Trans. Am er. Fish.oc., 1977, 106 (3) : 278-286

Catalog

    Article views (942) PDF downloads (653) Cited by()
    Related

    /

    DownLoad:  Full-Size Img  PowerPoint
    Return
    Return